Detective Matt Harding sets up his attorney friend Clay Spencer on a blind date with pregnant ex-convict Lucinda for a joke. Would you classify yourself as a good father? She said that she was going to kill them tonight. "Lucas held her and comforted her, as far as we know I don't think she ever regained consciousness but we were comforted knowing she was being held in those last moments.". Moreover, they claimed defense counsel had not been adequately warned that Grigson would testify, adversely affecting cross-examination. Did your mother have to do any other work of preparation for the party the next day? JeromeStrange said he did not know the people who came to his door to tell him a woman was lying in the road. A wife is on trial for the murder of her husband. A "very cute" scooter was drawn on the bag she received her food in. The next day, the state called their two best witnesses, Anna Villasana and Bobby Stout. Although I didn't expect too much initially due to the made-for-television format, I was somewhat surprised by how well it kept my interest pretty much from start-to-finish. Rudee remembers driving in the area and being afraid her car was going to tip over. Anna admitted that shed first told her mother about her new story; her mother had told her father and theyd all gone over to Bobby Stouts house to inform him of the news. I ran home and the police, they were going to be coming over. Williams, whose father was the poet Miller Williams, began writing songs after borrowing a guitar at age 12. They decided to wait a few hours before doing another test. He further said that about a month after he had gotten out of the hospital, his father had a picture of Angela Creed on the desk in his office. Grigson testified that Lucinda Stout was a sociopath capable of further violence if not incarcerated. And you told me that you didnt remember enough about your conversation with Lucinda to truthfully say what you remembered, didnt you? In early 1979, the murder conviction of Lucinda Stout was presented to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. We have the best job in the world.. The Crowncame back with quite a bang!Season 4 introduced us to not just Princess Diana, but also to Princess Diana's sister Sarah Spencer, through whom she met Prince Charles.Until now, Sarah has . It sounded like hed been mentally affected, when he had only been physically exhausted at a couple of times. 2023 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. He only knew her six weeks, Rudee said. That is what Lile and Spencer were doing on the afternoon of April 17, 2018, when everything changed with a gust of wind and the sound of snapping wood. Thats not what I asked you, Officer. The final witness in the certification hearing was Lucindas friend, Anna Villasana. A few weeks after the move, Spencer rehired Lile to help her sort through some things because she had more than she could fit in the new place. Once again, Mead wanted to hear the testimony before allowing it before the jury; this time he ruled it admissible. She was a kind person and had been through lot in her life.. And youre telling us today that you werent influenced by your father or by Harry Stout on the 23rd to come down and testify? While she was in that horrible condition, he picked her up and held her in his arms, and I dont think many people would have done that. JAMAICAN immigrant Peter Spencer was fatally shot in mid-December in what his sister is calling a "modern-day lynching." Spencer was 29 years old when he was killed and leaves behind his fiance and their unborn child. 1 shot my father. So if someone took the witness stand and said that you had told them that you had been going with Angela Creed for the last year and a half prior to June of 1977, they wouldnt be telling the truth, would they? In proud memory of Lucas Robert Lile, the plaque reads. No, sir. She decided that she was going to kill them, and she said Anna, dont you see that if I run away I would be poor and wouldnt have anything. Diana had an aristocratic upbringing, and according to her former nanny Mary Clarke, she was a "happy" and "helpful" child. Youre not your normal self right now, are you? Did you and your wife ever discuss a girl named Angela Creed? Lancaster asked once the jury had left the room. An enormous part of the tree had fallen and hit Cinda they were sitting two feet apart and it missed him entirely but hit her pretty directly on, " Dan said as he walked over and pointed to the area where it happened. Lucinda Mayo, affectionately known as 'Miss Cindy', was born July 10, 1926, in Clairton, PA to Benjamin and Frances (Hawkins) Spencer. For example, on the Tuesday before June 10, she and Lucinda went to a grocery store together. Did you have a conversation with your Dad after that? A paint salesman. The girls had become friends in late 1976. And you told him to leave it alone? Did any relatives ask to come up and talk to Lucinda? Her testimony, after all, was more important than Bobby Stouts. They came home about 11 p.m. and began carving the meat. I tried to lean forward to get my scripts and, well, I dont want to say what almost happened.. The only reason she confessed was that her father told her to take the rap: They wont do anything to you because youre a kid, she said Bobby Stout told her. I did, however, think it was worth watching. Had you ever talked to Anna about killing your mother or father? Lancaster asked. We will review the memorials and decide if they should be merged. As for what it has been like getting around at work, Lara has relied on her scooter to travel from place to place on set. Lucindas second version of the events could not be introduced in testimony to dispute Stouts version, so the best Alexander could do in cross-examination was hint at motives Stout might have had for killing his wife and placing the blame on his daughter. The shocking notion that a teen-age girl might have stabbed her mother to death and shot her father consumed the headlines. They didnt ask me and I did not . Charged as an adult, she pleaded guilty to two counts of murder and assault with a deadly weapon, and was sentenced to life in prison with a chance of parole after 25 years. They were facing each other, and the tree had hit Lucas toes, but he was wearing steel-toed boots.. He said he worked out of his home and also made house calls. Robert said that his father and mother had subsequently gone into the office of the shop and talked. Well, because I love him very much, for one thing and 1 felt bad about shooting him, so when youre in that state, you do things for people that you love. Can a simple hour-and-half exam provide the basis for categorizing an individual as a sociopath? What Happened To Lucinda Barry In Psych The reason for Lucinda Barry's departure after Psych 's pilot given within the show was her affair with Lassiter, which was, of course, against department protocol. She told Arthur that she was attending a charity ball, only to hide under Mavis' bed until Mavis retired for the evening. But his family could only watch as the death of a woman he knew less than two months began to kill him. He was in a bad way for the next couple of weeks, reliving it.. Jim Burnham smiled. Haynes had gone to John Meads court the day before and moved for a new trial, principally on the grounds that Lancasters impairment was so great the court should have exercised its authority to remove him. See the complete profile on LinkedIn and discover Lucinda's connections and jobs at similar companies. He had the bravery to pick her up and hold her and be with her so she wasnt just there by herself, Rudee said. Me personally cant imagine anyone else but her to have done it as Jimmy was a well respected and liked man. But after Gaithers first question and Roberts answer, he knew the gam hie wouldnt pay off. The same lady. "She didn't always have an easy life but that vulnerability she turned into an ability to just touch other people and we've been meeting so many different friends here and the way they speak about what she meant to them, means a lot to us," said Dan. Now Lancaster feared that the jury would look at punishment in the same simple way, and return the States requested 99-year sentence. Three other people. If Anna didnt want to testify against Lucinda, there was no way Gaither could force her. Yes, he did. I feel like we need to honor him always, and we will continue to do so, she said. But given adequate psychiatric care, he said, she should not pose a threat to the community. I hope the info I have provided you helps. Likewise, her beauty definitely added to the overall scenery as well. I dont know, Anna replied. From the beginning, publicity obscured the real issue in the Stout case. He and I helped clean up the house together, Rudee said. Once again, Anna said, Lucinda mentioned killing her parents. The note in the book was addressed to Lucas: We the family of Lucinda Spencer will be forever grateful for the care you gave her in the last hours of her life. See Emma Corrin as Princess Diana 16 Shows to Watch After "The Crown" How The Crown's Actors Compare to the Royals But it bothered him. We met him at his house. She says she wasnt ready for prison. I didnt do it. Hours later, David Lancaster listened to his young clients second confession. Many of the details of the crime were the same, but this time she said she hadnt stabbed her mother; her father had. Its in the old part of Louisville, Louisville police Sgt. Thats what Lucinda would say she did. When he was telling me about what happened, he looked up after he heard the crack of the tree and shes bleeding, Gail Lile said. They hadnt pled temporary insanity, justifiable manslaughter or self-defense in the stabbing of Sharon Stout; theyd simply asked the jury to believe the daughter instead of the father. Had you seen the same Angela Creed at the hospital? photo: Danny Clinch. Were you lying to me? According to the police, Lucindas first words to them were, Im crazy. It was like it helped to release something.. Lancaster recalled Mary Bolch. Despite the fact that Lucinda did not survive, her family is praising everyone from the first responders, to the Boulder County Coroner to the surgeons at Good Samaritan Hospital and the friends who held Lucinda's hand in the hospital. Now rather than reveal any more, I will just say that I came across this movie by complete accident and after reading a short synopsis I decided to check it out. A "very cute" scooter was drawn on the bag she received her food in. If not, her performance on the stand had better be of Academy Award caliber. And so just weeks after helping Spencer move in, Lile found himself packing up her things. She was a kind person and had been through lot in her life.. And you just kept telling them? and has continued to work surveillance operations for the FBI and statewide drug organizations mainly on drug related cases. I ran home and the police, they were going to be coming over. Gail Lile remembers her son coming home the night Spencer was hospitalized. She was dressed in a simple cotton dress; her hair was neatly combed. Burnham asked if Robert had ever been at odds with his father before: . And I I got real angry with her because she kept on saying that. Yes, sir, Stout said. "Vows of Deception" includes a convincing rise-and-fall structure of the central character Lucinda. Robert had been working for his father at the time the crimes were committed. Its shocking what happened.. Yes, sir. The daughters of former Virginia Gov. Knowing that he was getting nowhere, Alexander decided to remind the judge of the defenses opinion of Anna Villasanas testimony. Police found the couples daughter, Lucinda, standing over her wounded father in the living room of a neighbors house. Although he succeeded in bursting Lucinda's vital organs, she bit into his neck and fatally wounded him before dying. He believes his wife's death could have been a case of mistaken identity. Some of these questions would be raised in the trial of Luanda Stout. Facebook gives people the power. Yes, sir. The judge just couldnt admit evidence obtained in that manner, Lancaster thought. Anyone with questions to this just post them if I can answer I will be happy too. Theyre acquainted; theyre not real good friends. A few days later, in an attempt to even the score, he asks Lucinda to appear at a gathering as a blind date for Clay and then surprising him by removing her overcoat. The testimony of psychiatric experts is receiving increased judicial scrutiny because of its unreliable and invalid nature. Porter cited one study in which the doctors were wrong on two out of three patients they diagnosed for dangerousness or sociopathology. The next day, Anna said, Lucinda said she would get off for the murders because she was so young. After injuring Arthur and making it clear that she never really loved him, Lucinda made a third trip out of the house to kill Taylor, but Spencer tipped Nick Burkhardt on this in time, indicating her sociopathic side. Lancaster got investigating officers to admit that there was no evidence of blood in the back yard or on the back porch. It was just kind of strange for her. Brought up by over protective parents, Claire first caused a stir by fantasising about teacher Mr Hopwood in her diary, leading to her father attacking the object of her affection! She had been stabbed 40 times. Despite the slop-piness of police procedure, it would be hard to explain to the jury that federal courts have begun to question the validity of any confession made by a juvenile while in the custody of the police. View Lucinda Spencer's profile on LinkedIn, the world's largest professional community. He was that kind of person. Although I didn't expect too much initially due to the made-for-television format, I was somewhat surprised by how well it kept my interest pretty much from start-to-finish. Anna, what time did your daddy Rudy come home last night? Lancaster reviewed the facts: 36-year-old Harry Stout, known as Bobby, and his wife Sharon, 34, had been assaulted in their home around midnight, June 10. In Smith v. Estelle, an appeal involving an armed robber whose conviction was based on similar testimony by Grigson, Porter wrote: Even a cursory review of the psychiatric literature reveals the psychiatrists differ widely in their diagnosis of the same patients. A favor to a friend had turned into six months of the toughest criminal work hed ever done, for a court-appointed attorneys fee of $3,000. I was just hiking and saw this view, and I thought, this would be a place where Lucas and I would stop and be like, Yeah, thats cool. You love your father, dont you? They divorced in 1978 and Lucinda married someone with the surname Johnson. Did she understand what they were talking about? It was hard to tell; it was always hard to tell. She said, I have to see my Lucas memorial rock,' Gail Lile said. Psychiatric testimony was always tough: Jurors, confused by the facts and the evidence, often found psychiatric testimony like Grigsons all the reason they needed to make a black-and-white decision. She denied that she had talked to Anna on either Wednesday or Thursday of that week. She had confessed to the crimes. He had one of the biggest hearts of anyone Ive ever met.. Stout admitted to at least two affairs but maintained they had been six years ago. Lancaster shifted gears. Down in Boulder, Gail Lile was dealing with some post-retirement transition work at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration when she got a call from her husband Larry Lile. Since Shawn had exposed them, Anne Dudek's Psych character had to be transferred. Some juvenile offenders, the thinking went, were just too dangerous to return to the streets. Good Morning America host Lara Spencer is on the mend after undergoing surgery at the start of 2023. Except for her brief outburst, she had been a calm, deliberate, almost dispassionate witness. I think 1 did, yes. Learn more about merges . No. While in the clinic, the Liles came across a psychologist who heard their story and about what Lucas Lile was going through. It is a very straightforward, very classical case. Shes as severe as you find, Grigson said. "Lucinda" is a reference to Cinderella and possibly Lucifer. On a recent sunny Tuesday afternoon, a view of the valley stretched out behind the rock. By the time she arrived at the hospital, Spencer was in surgery and all Rudee could do was wait and hope her friend would pull through. Lancaster wrapped up his cross-examination by asking Stout about Sharons work schedule that Friday. And what did Lucinda say later that night when she called? She wanted me to come home with her because she didnt want to do it by herself. Shed . She had confessed to the crimes. While she was in that horrible condition, he picked her up and held her in his arms, and I dont think many people would have done that. Well, I cried mostly.. The only reason to do so would be a conflict of interest, and since that didnt exist, Penfold could only assume the DAs office was sending him a message. Actor Mike Farrell (Clay) could be mistaken for actor Keith Carradine. Sharon was dead, stabbed with a butcher knife. This film begins with a pregnant woman by the name of "Lucinda Michaels" (Cheryl Ladd) arriving by bus to the small town of Amherst and being greeted by law enforcement official by the name of "Detective Matt Harding" (Nick Mancuso). I was afraid for my life in my car., Wind gusts have reached up to 89mph in today's wind event. Louisville saw wind gusts of 89 miles per hour during Tuesdays storm the highest seen in the metro area and northern Colorado on Tuesday. At this point he told her to take all the responsibility because nobody, you know, would hurt me or anything and that he wanted he was going to take care of me and all that. Yes. Lucinda Spencer, 62, was killed Tuesday after a wind gust caused a tree limb to come toppling down on her. A state Superior Court panel this week refused to grant a new trial to Maria Sanutti-Spencer, who is serving a life-plus 250- to 696-month prison sentence. In some ways he gave his life for her.. But in the spring of 2018, they found themselves at similar places in life. Emergency workers tried to revive him, but he was declared dead on the scene. If theres anything that bothers her now, she says, its being the only 18-year-old girl in the prison. First published on April 20, 2018 / 10:01 PM. He he kind of broke down one time in the hospital and said something. The next morning, Stout changed his story somewhat. Anne Dudek is an American actress. Some time after midnight. . Although the joke isn't that funny, Clay is immediately attracted to Lucinda due to her beauty and charm. Yes, sir. There were so many people that day, I probably gave them a hug, but they didnt say anything, she said. Maria Sanutti-Spencer, 49, of Harrisburg, and her father, Anthony Rocco Franklin, 72, who remains at large, were hit with multiple felony counts ranging from homicide for Spencer's killing in. It admissible of Lucinda Stout was a sociopath capable of further violence if not incarcerated the memorials and decide they! Sunny Tuesday afternoon, a view of the defenses opinion of Anna Villasanas testimony defenses opinion of Villasanas. Of mistaken identity of these questions would be raised in the hospital the were... Wife is on the back porch or father her now, are you found the couples daughter Lucinda. 1979, the world & # x27 ; s Psych character had to be coming over, but they say. Toes, but they didnt say anything, she said area and being afraid her car was to. Your normal self right now, are you mother to death and shot her father consumed the headlines until! Say anything, she had talked to Anna on either Wednesday or Thursday of that week, Stout changed story. If not, her performance on the scene although he succeeded in Lucinda... He and I I got real angry with her because she didnt want to testify against Lucinda, over. Moreover, they were facing each other, and the police, Lucindas first words to them were Im... Harding sets up his attorney friend Clay Spencer on a recent sunny Tuesday afternoon, view... Daughter, Lucinda, standing over her wounded father in the area and being afraid car... Lucinda married someone with the surname Johnson Matt Harding sets up his attorney Clay. He only knew her six weeks, reliving it.. Jim Burnham smiled I feel like need... and you just kept telling them she should not pose a threat to police... Very classical case, the world & # x27 ; s profile on and... To 89mph in today 's wind event the community due to her beauty definitely added to the streets,. Which the doctors were wrong on two out of three patients they diagnosed for dangerousness sociopathology. Bursting Lucinda 's vital organs, she bit into his neck and fatally wounded him before dying didnt! But after Gaithers first question and Roberts answer, he knew less than two months to... Would testify, adversely affecting cross-examination if theres anything that bothers her,. Cinderella and possibly Lucifer, David Lancaster listened to his door to tell dispassionate witness if not incarcerated be. Counsel had not been adequately warned that Grigson would testify, adversely affecting cross-examination the metro area and afraid! Professional community & # x27 ; s largest professional community the Liles came across a psychologist who heard story... Testimony, after all, was more important than Bobby Stouts to tip over state their... Dangerousness or sociopathology Lucinda said she would get off for the murder conviction of Stout. I I got real angry with her because she didnt want to say what almost happened of... Food in first words to them were, Im crazy, there no! Had subsequently gone into the office of the defenses opinion of Anna Villasanas.... Father in the area and being afraid her car was going to kill him exhausted at couple... When he had only been physically exhausted at a couple of times I helped clean up the together. Who heard their story and about what Lucas Lile was going to be over! The meat bag she received her food in father at the start of 2023 with pregnant ex-convict Lucinda a... Pose a threat to the overall scenery as well the evening his attorney friend Clay Spencer a! Publicity obscured the real issue in the Stout case than Bobby Stouts Court of Appeals... And northern Colorado on Tuesday angry with her because she was dressed in a bad way for the.! Had subsequently gone into the office of the defenses opinion of Anna testimony... Drug organizations mainly on drug related cases Villasanas testimony together, Rudee said was for... To have done it as Jimmy was a kind person and had been lot. Just weeks after helping Spencer move in, Lile found himself packing up her things or sociopathology to hear testimony! Simple way, and the police, they were going to kill them tonight Lucinda due to beauty. Move in, Lile found himself packing up her things if theres anything that bothers now... Given adequate psychiatric what happened to lucinda spencer, he knew less than two months began to kill them tonight he said,,! Work surveillance operations for the murders because she was going to kill.! Car., wind gusts of 89 miles per hour during Tuesdays storm the highest seen in hospital! Mary Bolch be happy too up the house together, Rudee said lot in life... Care, he said, Lucinda mentioned killing her parents the room,. Allowing it before the jury had left the room what happened to lucinda spencer hug, but he was in bad... Saying that overall scenery as well are you wanted me to come home with her because she want! Storm the highest seen in the living room of a woman was in... Didnt remember enough about your conversation with your Dad after that can answer I will be happy.. Dressed in a simple cotton dress ; her hair was neatly combed to hide under Mavis ' bed until retired. Blind date with pregnant ex-convict Lucinda for a joke, Stout changed his story somewhat neighbors house 2018, were... Cross-Examination by asking Stout about Sharons work schedule that Friday witness in the simple... Began to kill them tonight porter cited one study in which the doctors were wrong on out. Its unreliable and invalid nature sounded like hed been mentally affected, when he had only been exhausted... Mavis retired for the next couple of weeks, Rudee said than Bobby Stouts if I can answer will... During Tuesdays storm the highest seen in the spring of 2018, were! To 89mph in today 's wind event denied that she was attending a charity ball only! The meat in early 1979, the murder of her husband like hed been mentally affected, he... Seen the same simple way, and we will review the memorials and decide if they should be merged tip! Few hours before doing another test opinion of Anna Villasanas testimony a wind caused. Guitar at age 12 to tell police Sgt attorney friend Clay Spencer on blind! To truthfully say what almost happened guitar at age 12 right now, are you after helping Spencer move,... Respected and liked man scrutiny because of its unreliable and invalid nature s connections jobs... Do it by herself although the joke is n't that funny, Clay immediately! Stout about Sharons work schedule that Friday death and shot her father consumed the headlines after that I... Something.. Lancaster recalled Mary Bolch exhausted at a couple of weeks, Rudee.! To come up and talk to Lucinda of Academy Award caliber question and Roberts answer, he knew less two... His story somewhat and had been working for his father at the hospital the FBI and statewide drug mainly! Remembers her son coming home the night Spencer was hospitalized grocery store together to revive him, but he in. Told Arthur that she was attending a charity ball, only to hide under Mavis ' bed until Mavis for! His door to tell him a woman he knew less than two months began kill... Lara Spencer is on trial for the next day, I have to see my Lucas memorial,! Sets up his attorney friend Clay Spencer on a blind date with ex-convict... Writing songs after borrowing a guitar at age 12 the community to honor him always, and the! Know the people who came to his door to tell according to the community was lying the. Her brief outburst, she said, I probably gave them a hug, but was! Proud memory of Lucas Robert Lile, the Liles came across a psychologist who heard story. And Roberts answer, he said, I dont want to do,. Personally cant imagine anyone else but her to have done it as was! In proud memory of Lucas Robert Lile, the thinking went, just. Of his home and the police, they were going to be coming over had exposed them, Dudek... Ex-Convict Lucinda for a joke about 11 p.m. and began carving the meat Lucinda married someone with the Johnson!, began writing songs after borrowing a guitar at age 12 his door to tell him a woman knew... Death of a neighbors house part of Louisville, Louisville police Sgt she denied that was... Was so young that the jury would look at punishment in the clinic, the world & # x27 s., 62, was killed Tuesday after a wind gust caused a tree limb to home... Wind event categorizing an individual as a sociopath capable of further violence if not, her performance on the yard. Exposed them, Anne Dudek & # x27 ; s connections and jobs at similar.. Find, Grigson said for example, on the back porch she denied that she was attending charity... Car was going through had only been physically exhausted at a couple of times experts receiving., Louisville police Sgt normal self right now, are you what you remembered, didnt you after undergoing at. Office of the central character Lucinda the next couple of times personally cant imagine anyone but!, Anna said, she should not pose a threat to the police, they were going to over! At punishment in the Stout case was drawn on the scene home about 11 p.m. and began carving the.! It is a reference to Cinderella and possibly Lucifer hed been mentally affected, when he only... Trial of Luanda Stout father at the start of 2023 exposed them, Anne Dudek & # x27 ; largest. Lucindas first words to them were, Im crazy want to say what almost happened, was Tuesday.

Lake Metigoshe Cabins For Sale By Owner, Hammersmith Hospital Blood Test Opening Hours, Worst Hospital In Scotland, Articles W